This is a pretty good card and would have impressed us more in every other set. Almost a hard removal option for Paladin considering that it’s a class that can easily trade a dude to clean up the 1/1. The problem is that it’s a Control Paladin card, and that’s an entity we haven’t seen in a long time and find no reason to see return anytime soon.
We’re looking forward to playing a bad 2-drop and then follow it up by playing bad 1-drops. That’s a bold strategy, Cotton. We’ll see if it pays off.
A worse Piloted Shredder with Lifesteal. Sure, potentially healing us for 8 is nice, but it’s also nice to have minions that effectively fight for the board, and this one doesn’t. Not sure why this is a class card since it’s so incredibly boring.
Ah. Sand Wasp makes sense now. We play a bad 2-drop and follow it up with bad 1-drops so you can buff the attack of this menacing 1-drop, which dies to a ping. This is all very exciting.
We now get to play a bad 3-drop so we can draw more bad minions that die to pings! To be fair, this card is better than Sand Wasp and Brazen Zealot since its draw effect could find its way to other decks rather than aggressive ones.
Blessing of Kings with taunt and divine shield. This is costed fairly, which is why it won’t see play. You generally want buffs in aggressive decks that can leverage their minions on the board to push more immediate damage. This card costs 2 more than Kings but doesn’t deal more damage on the turn its played. Its divine shield also encourages trading rather than pushing damage, so we just can’t see slower decks use this spell particularly well either. It’s no Spikeridged Steed.
A slightly better and stickier Master Swordsmith. That doesn’t inspire confidence. It’s a mech we don’t want to play in Mech Paladin, and just a very mediocre aggressive card in general.
Tip the Scales
Probably the most interesting Paladin card in this set. We can see a deck full of murlocs abusing this card with Prismatic Lens and cheating this out as early as turn 5. The problem is that it heavily restricts deck building, leaves us with a very one-dimensional tribal deck that’s extremely vulnerable to AOE. The deck thinning aspect is quite substantial with this kind of effect, so perhaps it will find another upside.
Sir Finley of the Sands
Players with PTSD from Baku can relax. Finley is more of a Justicar than a Baku, in the sense that it can gain small advantages over time, and it’s dependent on being drawn rather than being consistently present. A highlander deck is also not built to abuse a specific upgraded hero power, especially tempo-focused ones such as Rogue’s or Paladin’s. Even if Finley is played on turn 2, he can’t snowball the game like Keleseth does. A strong card but a little overhyped.
We must include about 10 reborn minions to complete this quest at a reasonable time. Doing so forces us into running a decent number of mediocre minions that makes our deck underwhelmingly weak. And when we finally complete the quest, we receive an equally mediocre reward that is terrible when we’re behind, which we will be, since our deck sucks. It’s a hard pass.
Saviors of Uldum Set Rank: 9th
Overall Power Ranking: 9th
Somehow, Paladin managed to receive an atrocious set in an expansion that could be known as one of the strongest. It feels like the Shaman set in Knights of the Frozen Throne. Finley is clearly the best Paladin card in Uldum, but even he may not be enough to carry a highlander deck to success since Paladin’s card pool depth doesn’t compare to other classes. We’re also not sure what a Highlander Paladin deck even wants to do.
Outside of Highlander decks, there really isn’t much promise elsewhere. Mech Paladin, the class’ strongest archetype today, may try to incorporate the quest in its build. However, Making Mummies looks like one of the weakest quests available and there’s no guarantee it will be an upgrade. Only Tip the Scales feels like a truly worthy build-around to try and work on in a Murloc Paladin deck.
Paladin has already been suffering from stagnation in its strategies during Rise of Shadows, and in Saviors of Uldum, things could get worse.